NewCo Renaming Update

First, a thank you to those who took time to submit names to consider for our new school. We know there’s been a lot of questions surrounding the process, and wanted to share an update along with some time frames for next steps. We are grateful for your patience, prayers, and thoughtful engagement as we continue this important work together.

Honoring the Mount Olive Name While Looking Ahead

We understand that for many, the name Mount Olive Lutheran School is deeply meaningful. It represents years of faithful sacrifice, service, and Christ-centered education. For some, the school name is tied to personal memories, family milestones, and a strong sense of identity. Feelings of disappointment or loss around a name change are real and understandable, and they deserve to be acknowledged with respect.

As these discussions unfolded, the governing bodies understood from the outset that no matter which name was ultimately chosen, there would be some disappointment with both the outcome and the process. Given the deep personal connections to the school and its history, that was expected. The goal was not to eliminate all disagreement, but to approach the decision with care, prayer, and a focus on what would best serve the school’s mission and future.

Regarding the Decision-Making Process

At a Mt. Olive Congregational meeting earlier in 2025, the possibility of a congregational vote on the school name was mentioned. As planning continued, our consultants from Blueprint Schools advised that a different approach would better serve both the school and the congregations. Based on their experience, selection of a name is most effective when it is grounded in research, mission alignment, and long-term sustainability rather than a popularity-based vote, which can unintentionally divide a community or favor familiarity over future clarity.

Following that guidance, a subcommittee was asked to prayerfully evaluate submitted name options from the congregations using clearly defined criteria tied to our shared mission. This group carried the responsibility of choosing a list of names that would best support enrollment, unity, outreach, and Christian education for generations to come. The final list of names was given to the NewCo Executive Council, NewCo Board of Directors, Pastors, and Faculty. Each ranked the list of names. In the end, the responsibility is given to the Board of Directors to choose the new school name based on all the information given to them through this process.

A Legacy That Continues

The faith, values, and commitment that have defined Mount Olive Lutheran School will remain. They continue through the people, the teaching, the Christ-centered mission, and the students whose lives are shaped every day. While the school name may change, the foundation built by Mount Olive remains firmly in place, and its influence will continue to bless our ministry well into the future.

Next Steps

The new school name will be announced in early January.

Q&A About The Name Change

Why was a new name needed at all?

Because the school is now a shared ministry serving more than one congregation, our joint leadership felt it was important to have a name that reflects unity and clearly communicates our Christ-centered mission to the wider community.

Why didn’t we vote on the name?

While a vote was discussed early on, our consultants from Blueprint Schools advised that name selection is best handled through research and mission alignment rather than a popularity vote, which can unintentionally create division or limit future clarity.

Why wasn’t the option to keep “Mount Olive” included?

After thoughtful discussion at a joint meeting of the Executive Council and Board of Directors, it was agreed that the school’s name should reflect its shared ownership and future direction. This decision was not about rejecting the past, but about choosing a name that best serves the school’s next chapter.

Who actually choses the name?

A Board of Directors subcommittee prayerfully reviewed name options using clear criteria tied to our mission, values, and long-term sustainability, following the guidance of Blueprint Schools. A final list of names was given to the Executive Council, Board of Directors, Faculty, and Pastors to rank for consideration when making a final decision. In the end, it is the responsibility of the Board of Directors to choose the new name.

Does this mean Mount Olive’s legacy is being erased?

Not at all. The faith, values, and commitment of Mount Olive Lutheran School remain at the core of the school. The name may change, but the foundation and legacy continue through the ministry itself.

What would you say to those who are disappointed?

We understand and respect those feelings. Change can be difficult, especially when it involves something meaningful. The governing bodies recognized from the beginning that not everyone would agree with the final name or the process used, and that reality was weighed carefully throughout the discussions. Our hope is that, over time, the mission and ministry of the school will help this new name become just as meaningful.

Will the school’s mission or teaching change with the new name?

No. The school remains fully committed to a Christ-centered education, strong academics, and nurturing Christian community. The name change reflects continuity of mission, not a change in beliefs or purpose.

Will the school’s mascot of “Chargers” change?

No. The school will remain the Chargers with our same school colors.

When will the new name take effect?

The transition will take place gradually to allow for clear communication and responsible stewardship of resources. During this time, you may see language such as “formerly Mount Olive Lutheran School” as the new name becomes established.

How can I support this transition?

Prayer, patience, and positive communication are deeply appreciated. By speaking confidently and kindly about the school’s mission and future, we help ensure a smooth transition and a strong witness to our community both internally and externally.